The Power of Student Choice in the Classroom to Lead to Success
We all know that offering student choice can have a profound impact on our students’ success. When we give them a voice in their learning environment, they’re more likely to follow directions, complete their work, and show respect to those around them. Back in my college days, as I studied behavior and explored countless classroom management strategies, one concept stood out. This was the power of incorporating choice in the classroom. This strategy has been a game-changer for me, helping to prevent power struggles and create a positive atmosphere.
The Power of Controlled Choices
Throughout my years of teaching, I’ve gained valuable insights into classroom behavior. Although I chose to pursue my principal certificate instead of becoming a certified BCBA, I’ve worked closely with BCBAs in my classroom. Along the way, I have learned a lot about what works when it comes to behavior management. One strategy that has made a significant difference is offering controlled choices. This approach is rooted in student choice and has been a game-changer when dealing with non-compliant students. Students often crave a sense of control, especially when they feel anxious. By providing our students with choices in the form of controlled options, we empower them. This can lead to more positive outcomes in challenging situations.
What is a Controlled Choice?
Controlled choices are one of the most effective strategies for incorporating student choice into the classroom. They give our students a sense of autonomy while still guiding them toward positive behaviors and outcomes. The beauty of this approach is its flexibility. Controlled choices can seamlessly be woven into many parts of the school day. Whether it’s during activities, transitions, or social interactions, there are countless opportunities to give our students structured options. For example, you might let them choose between markers or colored pencils for a project, decide how they complete tasks, or even pick a classmate to work with on a group assignment.
The key to making controlled choices work is keeping the options limited and manageable. Too many choices can overwhelm our students. A few well-curated options allow them to feel empowered without being paralyzed by decision-making. Research shows that when our students can make decisions, they’re more likely to stay engaged and on task. This sense of ownership over their learning environment can be incredibly motivating.
In my experience, integrating choice in the classroom through controlled options also fosters a sense of independence. Our students become more confident decision-makers. That confidence spills over into other areas of their learning. Whether choosing how to approach an assignment or collaborating with peers, these small moments of autonomy can lead to big gains in participation and motivation.
How to Implement Student Choice
Starting student choice in your classroom can be simple yet effective. The key is to start small and gradually increase the choices you offer. I implement student choice by giving my students options in their daily tasks. For example, I might let them choose between different assignments that target the same learning objective or allow them to pick where they want to sit during independent work time. These choices may seem minor, but they give my students control and ownership over their learning.
Another effective approach is to offer controlled choices during transitions or high-stress situations. When students feel anxious or resistant, giving them a few structured options, such as where to complete a task or which materials to use, can make all the difference. This helps them feel empowered while still guiding them toward the desired outcome.
Using visuals can also enhance student choice, especially for younger students or those who benefit from clear, concrete options. By displaying their choices visually through charts, picture cards, or digital tools, I make it easier for them to make decisions confidently and independently.
Ultimately, using student choice is about creating a balance between structure and autonomy. By providing choices that align with your classroom goals, you can help students take ownership of their learning. While doing so, you’ll be able to maintain a productive and positive environment.
Examples of Student Choice As Controlled Choices
Let me share a story to illustrate the power of student choice. When a student like Jesse refuses to do their work, it can be frustrating. Instead of insisting they complete it in a specific way, try offering student choice through controlled options. For example, ask Jesse if they prefer to complete the work with a pencil or pen. You might also ask if they would rather work at their desk or in a beanbag chair. By providing these choices, the work still gets done, but in a way that feels more acceptable and manageable to the student.
I’ve found that this strategy is particularly effective for students who crave control. By bringing student choice into their routine, our students feel that they have a say in how things are done rather than just following directives. This approach isn’t just beneficial for the teacher-student dynamic. I also teach paraprofessionals to use this strategy. When paraprofessionals offer student choice through controlled options, they can guide students away from power struggles and prevent those high-stress meltdowns. It’s all about finding a balance between what needs to be done.
Using Visuals to Help with Student Choice
Visuals are a powerful tool when it comes to choice in the classroom. Utilizing visuals for student choice strategies is incredibly effective, especially in high-stress situations. Visual aids provide clear, concrete options that help our students process their choices more easily. They reduce anxiety and promote a sense of control. In my classroom, I use visuals to present choices when my students need a break. For example, I might display a simple chart or images allowing my students to choose whether to take a break at their desks, move to a designated quiet corner, or use a sensory tool.
Visuals are helpful for our students who struggle with verbal instructions or need a little extra support in making decisions. By visually presenting student choice options, I can help them feel more secure and confident in their decision-making, even during high stress. This approach also ensures that my students understand their choices clearly and can make decisions more independently.
I encourage all my paraprofessionals and other staff members to use visuals when offering student choice. It’s a straightforward yet powerful way to reinforce controlled choices and avoid potential power struggles. Whether it’s through picture cards, posters, or digital displays, bringing visuals into your student choice strategies can make a big difference in how students respond and engage.
Grab these free Break Time choices in the Teach Love Autism store.
More Examples of Student Choice
Think about those tasks you don’t particularly enjoy, such as emptying the dishwasher. Even though it’s not something you want to do, having a choice can make it more manageable. You could empty the dishwasher while listening to your favorite music. You might choose to do it now or later, with the understanding that it must be done eventually. This same idea applies to our students in the classroom. By offering students choice in how or when tasks are completed, we give our students a sense of ownership over their responsibilities.
Allowing our students to make their own choices empowers them and increases their willingness to engage with the work. When our students feel they have some control over their tasks, they are more motivated to follow through. This doesn’t mean giving them complete freedom. It’s about offering structured choices that allow them to take responsibility in a manageable way. In my experience, student choice is a powerful tool for fostering independence and encouraging a positive attitude toward completing tasks.
How Student Choice Supports Social-Emotional Learning
When we bring student choice into the classroom, we’re not just promoting academic engagement. We’re also nurturing key social-emotional skills. Making decisions, even small ones, helps our students develop critical thinking and problem-solving abilities. It also gives them opportunities to practice responsibility and accountability for their actions.
Offering choice in the classroom empowers our students to take ownership of their learning while building confidence and self-esteem. For example, when a student chooses how they want to complete a task or where they want to work during independent time, they’re practicing self-regulation. They’re learning to assess what works best for them and take control of their own success.
Additionally, student choice encourages collaboration and empathy. When our students are given options to work with peers or select group activities, they learn to navigate social dynamics and respect the choices of others. These experiences contribute to a more inclusive and supportive classroom environment where every student feels valued.
Empowering Your Students With Student Choice
Establishing student choice in my classroom isn’t just about giving students options. It’s about empowering them to take control of their learning experience. When I provide structured choices, I allow my students to make decisions that matter. This helps them build confidence and independence. Student choice encourages a more engaging and supportive classroom environment. This could be through controlled choices, using visuals, or allowing them to take responsibility for how and when they complete tasks. By embracing this approach, I’m guiding my students academically and helping them develop essential life skills that will serve them well beyond the classroom.
Save for Later
Remember to save this post to your favorite Special Education Pinterest board to refer back to this helpful information on student choice.
